Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Homemade Laundry Detergent: Does it work?


My husband has some extreme allergies, so we have to be very careful with detergents. Plus, I seem to have respiratory issues with most cleaning products. I’ve switched to using a vinegar/water mix to clean, but I’ve always wondered about homemade detergent. I’ve read dozens of different blogs, and most same the same thing. It works just as well, if not better than the traditional detergent plus it’s safer on the environment and considerably cheaper.

I decided to try to make it. I was met with resistance from the husband. His only encounter with people using homemade detergent is “the hippies that smell like feet.” I told him I would make some, and he could do a blind smell/feel test, and if he could tell a difference, I’d go back to our All Free & Clear.

So, yesterday I made a powder detergent:
  1. 2 bars of Fels Naptha soap that I ground up in the food processor ($1.94)
  2. 4 cups Borax ($1.41)
  3. 4 cups Washing Soda ($1.89)
  4. 4 cups Baking soda ($1.26)
That’s a total of $6.50 for my homemade detergent with 56 washes. (I’ve heard to use anywhere from 2 Tablespoons to ¼ cup of detergent. The 56 washes is based on using ¼ cup of detergent.) I spent $12.99 for our All Free & Clear with 56 washes last time. So, my homemade detergent will be $0.11 per load if I continue to use ¼ cup. If I decrease to 2 Tablespoons, it will be $0.058 per load. The All Free & Clear is $0.23 per load. I do approximately 4 loads of laundry a week, so that’s a savings of $25 a year. (If I can decrease my usage, I’ll save $36 a year.)

I mixed all of that in a large pourable container that I picked up at Walmart, during the afore mentioned “last trip ever.” It took me about 5 minutes to do the entire thing.

The experiment:
I split our load of light colors (towels, socks, underwear, etc) into two piles. I split each pair of A’s socks so that he could look at/smell them side by side. I used the exact same water level and temperature and left out any vinegar or fabric softener. (I use white vinegar as a fabric softener.)

The results:
In just eying things, the towels and wash cloths are much fluffier with the homemade detergent than the All which shocked me. The stack is at least 50% bigger if not double. Visually, there isn’t a difference between the socks.

For the smell, I actually prefer the homemade detergent. It has a much crisper smell than the All Free & Clear. The All pile smelt almost heavy. (I know Free & Clear should devoid of any fragrance but I guess not.)

As for the husband…A did the test when he got home from work. When he first picked his pile, he got it wrong. I started laughing but then he tried to say he didn't smell or touch them and just guessed. (eye roll) Once he smelt them, he said there was a noticeable difference...that the homemade pile smelt weird. (It smells like soap.) He also said that the All once felt "slicker" which meant they are "cleaner." I'm pretty sure that's because the detergent leaves residue. It could also explain why my towels are fluffier. (Hence the reason you aren’t supposed to wash fleece in liquid detergent.)

The Final Decision:
If it were up to me, we’d be switching. I’m all about saving money, protecting the earth and sticking it to the man but A will be the deciding factor. In the long run, it’s anyone’s guess...but I have 55 more loads of homemade detergent!

Next up: Homemade Stain Remover

No comments:

Post a Comment